I mentioned yesterday that this is a multi-part series of how I grade the home field edges. On the right-hand pages of the magazine for all 138 teams (North Dakota St and Sacramento St added this year), I list the home field advantage. I think college football crowds are the best in sports and some teams have larger home field edges than others. In Las Vegas the standard is to give 3 points to the home team. I believe there is a large difference in home field edges in college football. Traveling to face Mississippi St and having to face the cowbell noise is a daunting task. Some stadiums that may not be 100,000 but are very loud like Oregon and Washington which are a lot tougher venues than traveling to Akron or Connecticut. Last year my home field edges in the magazine ranged from 2 to 5.5.
The last two days I gave you the straight up records of all 136 teams for the last three and five years excluding 2020. I excluded 2020 as most games did not have any crowd at all so there really was no home field edge. Some teams played full schedules, some teams played 4 games, and some played none but the empty stadiums would have skewed the data. Today I bring in the great equalizer: the Las Vegas Spread. In a perfect world Vegas gets 50% of its bets on one side and 50% on the other side and they collect the juice (10%) with no risk. Yesterday I showed that home teams win roughly 64% of their games straight up and some teams had a perfect record over 3 years. I gave a 6.0 only for 100% but in the ATS world I had to grade on a curve as no team could accomplish 100% as Vegas would adjust the lines each week to balance the action until they were overpriced. You will notice the Graded on a curve column has been added.
In 2022 three teams managed a perfect ATS record at home despite the 3 teams combining for a 4 straight up losses. In the straight up records, the teams at the top are almost always the powerhouses. Vegas evens things out so the undefeated spread teams were far from your normal blue bloods in Oregon St, Duke, and Louisiana Tech. In ‘23 only one team managed a perfect ATS record at home and that was Arizona at 6-0. Three teams had 6-1 marks, and they were Kansas St, Kansas and Jacksonville St. In 2024 Arizona St was the only team to be undefeated ATS at home (6-0 SU and ATS). Indiana was 7-1 ATS, Colorado 5-1, Baylor 4-1, Marshall 5-1, Ohio U 5-1, FIU 5-1, UTSA 5-1 and Georgia Southern 5-1 ATS. Last year four teams were unbeaten ATS at home and they are not the names you might expect. San Diego St, Toledo, Utah St and USF (5-0-1). The teams at the bottom in 2024 were both in the ACC as North Carolina and Wake Forest each went 0-7 ATS in their home games. Last year only one team failed to cover a home game and it was Army (0-5 ATS) with Louisville next closest at 1-7 ATS.
I include the spread in my calculations, not to figure out which are the best teams to wager on but those teams that lived up to or beat Vegas’s expectations on a weekly basis. Michigan is 18-2 SU at home in the Big House the last 3 years but just 6-13 ATS in that span.
Let’s look at the last three years ATS records for each team at home.
In 2023Oregon State was at the top of the chart last year with a super 15-3 ATS mark the previous 3 years. Oregon St held onto the #1 spot last year as they went 18-2 the last 3 years ATS for a remarkable 90%. I mentioned grading on a curve. 18-2 in the Straight Up category would have been worth a 5.4 grade but in the ATS category they are the only team to grade at 6.0. In ’23 Tulane had an impressive 3-year mark of 15-5 75% and that qualified for a 5.96 grade in this graded on a curve basis. Vegas evened things out for them and even with the Green Wave going 6-2 straight up at home in ‘23 Vegas priced them high, and they were just 2-6 ATS. Last year I noted that Oregon St with a new head coach and being left out of the Power 5 might take a similar drop in ’24 and they were indeed just 2-5 ATS. Kansas used to have one of the worst home field edges but under Lance Leipold they are a super 13-5 ATS at home the last 3 years. That ties them with 3 teams you would not expect to see at the top in Ohio U, Georgia Southern and Jax St. The Powers listed near the top are Alabama, LSU and the Blue turf of Boise St all at 14-6 ATS. Charlotte is just 3-14 ATS at home the last 3 years but now has Tim Albin from Ohio (at top) coming in. The worst Power 5 teams over the last 3 years are Purdue (4-15), Stanford (5-13) and North Carolina (6-14).
While home teams win 64% of their home games straight up, the home team should be closer to 50% ATS if Vegas is doing their job. In 2025 teams were just 1275-1273 ATS the last previous years. As I mentioned above Vegas’s goal is a 50% margin and they basically hit it at 50.1% so they do a great job evening it out! Last year the home teams had a slight edge at 456-416 and 2022 dropped off which was 422-425 so the three-year totals are now 1311-1264 50.9%.
The top teams in the three-year totals are Boise St (15-4), Utah St (14-4) , Georgia Southern (14-4), Alabama (16-5) and Hawaii (15-5). Ball St is next and despite being just 15-13 SU at home the last 3 years they have gone 12-4 ATS! At the bottom Charlotte is just 3-14 ATS at home with Georgia St 4-14. There are more P4 teams near the bottom than at the top with Purdue (5-16), Arkansas (6-14), Mich St (6-140, UCLA (5-11) all in the bottom 10. I mentioned Michigan but evidently Georgia is paying a steep price in Vegas when at home and despite 19-1 SU at home the last 3 years they are just 6-13 ATS!
It is very tough to get a 6 grade for a home edge and the ATS factor is part of that reason. Note that the actual top 3-year ATS grade is 4.74 so I had to also grade this category on a curve and both numbers go into the computer’s equation for home field edge. Tomorrow I will have the ATS records for each team over the last five years at home.
This years magazine is 376 pages and the biggest and best ever. Here are the different ways you can order the magazine.
Option #1 – Pick one up at your local Barnes and Noble or Books-a-Million store. When you go into a Barnes and Noble you get two different cover choices in each store! The official on sale date is July 4th but it is hitting some stores sooner. It is also available at Books-a-Million which all have the national cover. These two distributors are our exclusive vendors of the magazine, and they are not available at Walmart’s, Walgreens, Grocery Stores, other bookstores or drug stores so save your gas. The only two brick and mortar store they are available are Barnes and Noble and Books-A-Million.
Option #2 – Buy the Hard copy of the magazine at philsteele.com or call 1-866-918-7711. The total cost depends on where you live and which of the four types of shipping you choose. It will cost you in the ballpark of $10 for shipping and tax. The biggest advantage of buying online is that When you buy the Hard copy you GET the DIGITAL version of the magazine ($19.99) for FREE and it is updated thru September. Your digital access begins immediately when you purchase. You also get your choice of covers (National, SEC, Midwest, Southwest, West or East Coast) as these are generally mailed out the same or next business day as the order. Order Here!
Option #3 – Buy the digital magazine. The best thing about the digital magazine is that it is updated all the way thru the month of September. If a coach gets fired (that has happened the last couple of years) we update it. If a player is injured and out for the year we CIRCLE him in the magazine. If a player is added late (very rare) we put him in. Any changes to the team from the start of June thru the month of September is updated in the digital version. When you go to the philsteele.com store you will not see a picture there, you need to click on Digital Editions and order it there. It will be activated immediately giving you instant access. Order the Digital Here!
Option #4 – Order the VIP Bundle – The price of the VIP bundle is $44.95. With the VIP bundle you get the National Cover of the magazine. All VIP’s received EXCLUSIVE ACCESS to the digital version of the magazine for one week, but that bonus is gone as the digital is now available for everyone. You receive two magazines PLUS the Digital Magazine. You also receive FOUR Free issues of my Inside the Pressbox Newsletter ($20 per issue – $80 value) which gives you my Forecast and my computers forecast on EVERY FBS game each week. You also receive access to Phil Steele Plus ($25 per month) for the months of June, July, August and September! The VIP Bundle also includes SHIPPING so it is basically just $10 more than ordering the magazine by itself! Order the Reg VIP Bundle Here!!
Option #5 – THE BEST BUY – Order the Super VIP Bundle – The price of the SUPER VIP bundle is $74.95. With the Super VIP Bundle you receive
TWO magazines INCLUDING SHIPPING ($69 value!), EXCLUSIVE ACCESS to the digital version for one week (that happened already), order shipped next business day. Use the 2nd magazine when your first one gets dogeared or sell/give it to a friend.
Digital magazine ($19.95 value) FREE – The digital magazine is updated thru September (see option 3) and you get immediate access to the digital version upon purchase.
Four Issues of my Inside the Pressbox newsletter ($80 value) which gives you my forecast and my COMPUTERs forecast on EVERY FBS games each week (including FBS vs FCS) the same bonuses that the VIP’s get. You also receive…
FCS Digital Magazine ($25) FREE – Two full pages on Every FCS team laid out the same way the pages are for the FBS magazine. There are 128 FCS teams so over 250 pages!
NFL Digital Magazine ($15) FREE – Four full pages on Every NFL team and a Fantasy Football section!
Phil Steele Plus ($99 value) ENTIRE SEASON FREE – This is a tremendous addition. If you purchase the full year access to Phil Steele Plus it is $99 but you get it included in the Super VIP Bundle Purchase the Super VIP Bundle now and get the entire year of Phil Steele Plus FREE!! Here is a link to all the great info available on Phil Steele Plus including the schedule predictor! Order the Super VIP Bundle Here!!
Check out all of our Great Products on PhilSteele.com Store Here!
